Skip to Content
MTC multistate tax Commission
image description
An intergovernmental state tax agency whose mission is to promote uniform and consistent tax policy and administration among the states, assist taxpayers in achieving compliance with existing tax laws, and advocate for state and local sovereignty in the development of tax policy.
  • The Commission
    • About Us
    • Email Updates
    • MTC History
    • Member States
    • Multistate Tax Compact
    • Programs & Committees
    • Bylaws
    • Officers & Executive Committee Members
    • Executive Committee Archive
    • Litigation Committee Archive
    • Annual Reports
    • Policy Statements & Resolutions
    • Public Participation Policy
    • News
    • Paull Mines Award
    • Wade Anderson Memorial Award
    • Annual Business Meeting Archive
  • Uniformity
    • About Uniformity
    • Uniformity Charter
    • Uniformity Process
    • Adopted Uniformity Recommendations
    • Uniformity Meeting Archives
    • Standing Subcommittee
    • Current & Recent Uniformity Projects
    • Article IV
    • Amicus Briefs
  • Nexus
    • Multistate Voluntary Disclosure Program
    • Multistate Voluntary Disclosure Application
    • Member States
    • Nexus Committee
    • State Tax Amnesties
    • State Tax Amnesties Archive
  • Audit
    • Audit Member States
    • Taxpayer-Initiated Joint Audits
    • Audit Committee
    • Audit Committee Archive
    • Audit Training Programs
    • Resource Documents
    • Audit Program Links
  • Events & Training
    • Past MTC Meetings
    • Upcoming Training Events
    • Faculty Biographies
    • Training Program Fees
    • Frequently Asked Questions
    • Training Program
  • Resources
    • Uniform Sales & Use Tax Resale Certificate - Multijurisdiction
    • Policy Research
    • Amicus Briefs
    • Legislation
    • Alternative Dispute Resolution
    • Tax Stratification and Estimation Program (TSEP)
    • Employment Opportunities
    • Legal Internship Program
    • State Sales & Use Tax Registration Forms
    • Research, Presentations, & Publications
    • Career Information Websites
Alabama v. CSX

Alabama-v-CSX-(1).jpgOn November 9, 2018, the MTC filed an amicus brief in the United States Supreme Court supporting Alabama’s petition for writ of certiorari in Alabama v. CSX. The MTC encouraged the court to grant the petition in order to clarify its previous holdings in the case, which involves the question of whether rail carriers may be subjected to a fuel tax that is parallel but not identical to those imposed on motor and water carriers.  CSX has argued that these taxes discriminate against rail carriers in violation of the 4-R act, 49 U.S.C. § 11501(b)(4).  In its prior holdings in this case, the Court determined that the scope of the 4-R Act is extremely broad—encompassing all manner of taxes and tax issues and potentially diverse comparison classes that may give rise to claims of discrimination.

In its brief, the MTC noted that, while the Court has also said a claim of discrimination under the act may fail if it cannot identify one or more “substantially similar” comparison groups, or if the state shows that the differential treatment is sufficiently justified, those concepts do not appear grounded in any particular established principles.  Speaking from an administrative perspective, the MTC asked the Court to grant certiorari and draw a more defined boundary for this federal preemption.

You can read the brief by clicking here .
 

Quick Links
  • MTC Past Events
  • Member States
  • Programs & Committees
  • State Intercompany Transactions Advisory Service (SITAS)
  • Strategic Planning Committee
Upcoming Events

55th Annual Meetings

August 1 - 4, 2022
in Anchorage, Alaska
Schedule of Events  
Online Registration

State Taxation of Partnerships Work Group

June 27, 2022 - Held bi-weekly 
at 3:00 p.m. Eastern
Via GoToMeeting
View Agenda

Programs & Resources
  • Legislation
  • Multistate Voluntary Disclosure Program
  • Uniform Sales & Use Tax Certificate
  • Adopted Uniformity Recommendations
About MTC
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Terms of Use
  • Resources
  • Privacy and Refund Policy
Committees
  • Executive Committee
  • Audit Committee
  • Litigation Committee
  • Nexus Committee
  • State Intercompany Transaction Advisory Service Committee
  • Strategic Planning Committee
  • Uniformity Committee
The Commission
  • Member States
  • Multistate Tax Compact
  • Bylaws
  • MTC Officers & Members
  • Annual Reports

Back to top